Garrett County restaurants capture the flavors of Maryland with unique, scratch-made cuisine, tons of history and farm-to-table products
In Garrett County, restaurants cook up dishes that provide a look into Maryland’s pastoral region, which provides optimal environments for fresh ingredients and free-range, grass-fed animals. Coupled with dedicated chefs and restauranteurs, your group can find the perfect fare for your family affair. From scratch-made baked treats to salty meats and creamy cheeses, sublime flavors cater to everyone in Garrett County.
Contact Garrett County, Maryland and Discover More family reunion-worthy locations when you subscribe for FREE to Destination Reunions today.
Casselman Creamery in Garrett County
Casselman Creamery has loads of delicious treats and plenty of space for your group to enjoy them. Photo credit: Casselman Creamery
Stop by Casselman Creamery to sample delicious artisan cow cheese and watch how it’s processed behind a large window. The creamery uses locally sourced milk from an Amish dairy farm in Casselman Valley to make its delicious products. Share fresh cheese curds, fine-aged cheddar, and feta with your group, or enjoy fresh homemade breakfast sandwiches, salads, and pasta dishes in the adjacent Farmer’s Table Eatery. Families can also create a catering menu for your group for a delicious celebration. Casselman also has a meeting room that can be booked for meetings and events.
Try the cheese at Casselman Creamery
Brenda’s Pizzeria in Maryland
For Garrett County restaurants serving the freshest pizza pies, Brenda’s is the place to bring your group. Tossing scratch-made pies since 2001, Brenda’s is a popular, family-friendly pizzeria serving up the freshest and best local ingredients in their tasty meals. The atmosphere is fun and perfect for groups, with a beautiful view of the lake. And you’ll find more than just pizza at Brenda’s; there are also salads, pasta and sandwiches on the menu. Try the Abbondanza pizza, meaning abundance in Italian, and for the amount of food it provides for the whole family. Grab a few tables in the family establishment for a shared meal, get take-out to bring back to the hotel, or order delicious take-and-bake items.
Try the pie at Brenda’s Pizzeria
Casselman Inn is a staple Garrett County restaurant with plenty of space for your family reunion.
Casselman Inn in Garrett County, MD
The historic inn, hotel and restaurant is a great place to host a family reunion dinner. Casselman Inn’s cuisine specializes in fresh, simple country food made in the Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish traditions of the owners. The menu includes homemade breads, cakes and pies prepared in the bakery downstairs, and visitors are welcome to watch them be prepared before dinner. Guests can eat in the original wood-floored dining room or a newer space that accommodates 125 people. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner, the casual atmosphere and large dining room provides space and food options for everyone.
Dine at the Casselman Inn Restaurant
Garrett County’s Rolling Pin Bakery
The bakery and deli serve homemade bread, cookies, muffins, whoopie pies, and other tasty treats for reunion groups. Guests looking for a meal can try deli salads, paninis, wraps and mac-and-cheese made fresh daily. If you are visiting during the holidays, Rolling Pin makes specialty seasonal bread and holiday cookies, and they always have pumpkin rolls along with delicious seasonal and fruit pies. Scratch-made breakfasts include sausage gravy and biscuits, and cinnamon roll pancakes.
Rolling Pin Bakery provides superior scratch-made goods
Firefly Farms in Maryland
Your group will love FireFly’s gourmet selection of fine artisan cheeses, charcuterie and cured meats, local grass-fed beef, tinned and smoked seafood, crackers, jams, jellies, tapenades, chocolate, and sweets. The Deep Creek Market Café offers freshly brewed espresso, cappuccino, lattes and loose-leaf tea in addition to paninis and chips. Adults can enjoy wine and cheese while the kids can try a grilled peanut butter and jelly sandwich or grilled cheese.
Cheese, meats, espresso and more at FireFly Farms
When you subscribe for FREE to Destination Reunions, you have access to top pro tips for successful family travel, plus locations that are made for family reunions. Contact Garrett County, Maryland for more travel information.
